Whitepaper: Quantrix and Excel: 3 Key Differences
This whitepaper educates spreadsheet users about three key conceptual and practical differences between Quantrix Modeler and Excel.
A better understanding of what sets Quantrix and traditional spreadsheets apart will help financial and quantitative modeling professionals evaluate the impact Quantrix Modeler can have on their modeling success.
This paper examines:
- Quantrix matrices compared to worksheets
- Quantrix items compared to spreadsheet rows and columns
- Quantrix formulas compared to spreadsheet cell-based formulas.
Spreadsheet software has been commercially available for more than 25 years and is an appropriate solution for many tasks commonly performed by the financial and data modeling community. However, the spreadsheet has its limitations when creating more complex models that employ multiple dimensions, formulas, and immense data sets.
Spreadsheet software has been commercially available for more than 25 years and is an appropriate solution for many tasks commonly performed by the financial and data modeling community.
However, the spreadsheet has its limitations when creating more complex models that employ multiple dimensions, formulas, and immense data sets. Complex spreadsheets become inherently inflexible and prone to error as they grow – thus undermining confidence in the data and insight they produce.
Today’s businesses, government agencies, non-profit organizations, and academic institutions require a tool that enables more efficient and scalable modeling while being intuitive to the user.
“If I could sum up the difference between Quantrix and Excel, I would say that the former is algebra and the latter arithmetic. We get further with algebra rather than arithmetic.”
Ajith Prasad, National University of Singapore
Quantrix Matrix compared to the Worksheet
Quantrix models consist of multidimensional matrices. Spreadsheets, by contrast, are two-dimensional worksheets that come in workbooks. While matrices have features in common with worksheets, there are important differences.
It may be helpful to first define what a dimension is in practical terms. Take, for example, a Profit & Loss (P&L) budget. When building a P&L budget by month for one year, one dimension would be represented by month and a second dimension would be a P&L line item such as Revenue, Expenses, Profit, etc. Other typical dimensions in a business model could include Business Unit, Subsidiary, Product, Channel, Region, Scenario, or Case.
In the simplest case, there is a two-dimensional model Month x P&L Line Item. It is relatively easy to create this model in one Worksheet. However, if the business has multiple subsidiaries, it may be necessary to prepare this budget by subsidiary as well. With the introduction of subsidiary, the model has now expanded to three dimensions: Month x P&L Line Item x Subsidiary.
To accomplish this in a spreadsheet, one typical approach would be to set up the budget for each subsidiary on a separate worksheet.
This is where Quantrix diverges from a spreadsheet. Matrices in Quantrix support more than two dimensions.
In fact, Quantrix supports up to 16 dimensions.
Therefore, it is unnecessary to take the same design approach as with a spreadsheet. Rather, the third dimension, subsidiary, can be added to the P&L Budget by simply inserting a new category.
The advantages for the financial modeler with this approach are as follows:
- Economy: Standard P&L formulas for items like gross profit or EBITDA, which will apply to any subsidiary, are written just once.
- Agility: It is necessary to add more years or additional line items only once (rather than repeating the change in each worksheet in a spreadsheet) and the change will apply to all subsidiaries.
- Insight: To compare and contrast the subsidiaries, simply move the category tiles in the matrix to get the desired perspective.
Once again, Quantrix matrices are multidimensional. Two-dimensional structures, which must be replicated in a spreadsheet to accommodate extra dimensions, can be managed more efficiently in just one matrix in Quantrix.
“We had multiple dimensions we wanted to analyze, and we were able to chunk down to a huge amount of data and do something productive with it.”
Steven Bailey, DeLorme Inc.
Quantrix Items and Categories Compared to Spreadsheet Row
Most financial and data modeling professionals are used to working with fixed rows and columns in a spreadsheet, e.g. A, B, C, D and 1, 2, 3, 4. Columns are represented by letters and rows by numbers. In Excel, these references cannot be changed. Rather, meaningful row and column labels are defined in cells.
Quantrix uses the term “items” instead of rows and columns because the position of the items is not fixed. With simple drag-and-drop navigation, users can move column items so they are represented as rows, and vice versa. In Quantrix, it is also possible to change the name of an item. Items can have generic labels like A, B, C, 1, 2, 3, or they can have meaningful labels like Revenue, Costs, Profit, 2006, 2007, and 2008.
Items belong to categories in Quantrix and categories are defined by category tiles. Category tiles are moved by drag-and-drop to manipulate the position of the items. A category, and the items belonging to it, can be used elsewhere in a model. In a P&L budget model, for example, there may be category, Year, with items, 2006, 2007 and 2008.
This model may also require the creation of a Balance Sheet and a Cash Flow statement in separate matrices. In this case, it may be desirable to model the Balance Sheet and Cash Flow for the same years as the P&L.
Instead of creating new Year categories in the Balance Sheet and Cash Flow matrices, simply link the Year category and all its items from the P&L matrix to the two new matrices. This automatically creates the required years.
The powerful capability of linking a dimension, such as Year, from one section of a model to another is not possible in Excel and is important to consider when building models in Quantrix.
In addition to eliminating the replication of labels in new matrices, there are other benefits:
- Simplicity. Formulas are much simpler, because they are able to cross reference the proper items. For example, the first line of the cash flow may be Net Profit. Net Profit comes from the P&L. So, in the Cash Flow, only one formula is required that says “Net Profit = P&L::Net Profit”. This formula will automatically return the proper figure for each Year from the P&L matrix.
- Automation. When making changes to the linked category in one matrix, the same
change will automatically update the other matrices. In the previous example, if the P&L budget model is extended to 2009 by adding a new item, it will automatically appear in the Balance Sheet and Cash Flow matrices. Existing formulas will automatically apply to the new year – there is no need to manually copy and paste.
In summary, when setting up multiple matrices in a Quantrix model, remember that common categories, such as Year can be linked across matrices to greatly simplify logic and model maintenance on an on-going basis.
“In a traditional spreadsheet, a model involving a lot of data and several scenarios often becomes complicated and hard to follow. In Quantrix, a complex model can have a simple structure”
Philip Turner, Turner Analysis and Advisory
Quantrix Formulas Compared to Spreadsheet Cellbased Formula
Writing formulas in Quantrix is more efficient and transparent. A common practice developed by spreadsheet users is writing formulas in cells by clicking on the cell and hitting the equals (=) key. When that formula is needed in other cells, the original formula is copied and pasted into the new cells.
In Quantrix, formulas are not written in cells. Instead, they are written in a separate formula section just below the matrix. They are also written to refer to the item or category for which the formula should calculate.
Furthermore, formulas in a spreadsheet have no reference to the left of the equals (=) sign. This is due to the fact that the left-hand side of the formula is always the cell reference itself. Writing formulas in this manner is not particularly intuitive. If a user were to stand at a white board and explain how to calculate Current Assets in a Balance Sheet, she would likely write it like this:
Current Assets = Cash + Accounts Receivable
Rather than this:
= Cash + Accounts Receivable
Or, if Cash and Accounts Receivable are in cells B2 and B3, almost certainly not like this:
= B2 + B3
Formulas in Quantrix are written the way that the human brain intuitively conceives andexpresses them. If Current Assets equal the sum of Cash and Accounts Receivable, then the Quantrix formula will be written like this:
Current Assets = Cash + Accounts Receivable
Again, the Quantrix formula is not written in the cell. It is written to refer to an item or category
(in this case an item called Current Assets). This feature allows the formula to apply to all instances of Current Assets or, for example, to all periods in a Balance Sheet. Quantrix users gain important benefits writing formulas this way:
- Efficiency: Users maintain far fewer formulas than with spreadsheets. In the Balance Sheet example above, if the user were to develop a five-year plan by month, there would be 60 instances of “Current Assets”. In spreadsheets, there will be 60 formulas. In Quantrix, there is only one.
- Scalability: In spreadsheets, it is necessary to copy and paste formulas to new cells to extend the model to future years. In Quantrix, the formulas will apply and update automatically. There are no new formulas and no manual steps.
- Confidence: If the calculation of Current Assets is modified to include Short-term Investments, that formula change must be carefully copied and pasted by hand to all the other cells in a spreadsheet. In Quantrix, only one formula is modified. The validation
is performed on only one formula which eliminates a major source of errors.
- Transparency: The Quantrix formula is written in real words and is therefore transparent, easy to understand, and selfdocumenting. It is not necessary to write formulas in cells and manually copy and paste to other related cells. Rather, formulas are written once to apply to
items or categories, which greatly simplify the logic and validation of the model.
This paper has examined three important differentiators between Quantrix Modeler and Excel.
While appropriate for simpler financial modeling tasks, spreadsheets quickly encounter limitations as complexity and dimensionality increase.
Quantrix is designed as an easy-to-use tool to address complex business and quantitative modeling challenges. It is a departure from the traditional spreadsheet paradigm and offers a new perspective in approaching modeling tasks.
Quantrix Modeler offers important benefits including modeling agility, simplicity, transparency, and automation to deliver greater confidence and business insight for financial and quantitative modeling professionals.
“Quantrix will automatically apply the formula across the third dimension without you having to re-do a lot of existing work. That is dramatic”
Kyle G. Lundstedt, VaRish, Inc